153 guides · All researched, none sponsoredCanada & USA editions
Ice Makers & Frozen Treats

Best Undercounter & Built-In Ice Makers in Canada & the USA (2026): 8 Plumbed Picks for Kitchens & Home Bars

Best Undercounter & Built-In Ice Makers in Canada & the USA (2026): 8 Plumbed Picks for Kitchens & Home Bars

If you are shopping for the best undercounter ice makers, you are shopping for a different species of appliance. A built-in ice maker is plumbed into your water line, slides into a 15- or 18-inch cabinet bay — often the slot a trash compactor or dishwasher leaves behind — and then produces and stores ice around the clock: no filling tanks, no emptying melt water, no countertop footprint at all. For a home bar or a household that entertains constantly, it is the difference between planning ice and simply always having it.

The decisions that matter here are installation decisions. Do you have a floor drain below the unit (gravity drain) or do you need a model with a built-in pump? Is your bay 15 or 18 inches wide? And which ice do you actually want — fast cloudy crescents, uniform clear cubes, or slow-melting gourmet cubes? We built this ranking from Bob Vila’s researched undercounter picks — their team considered more than 25 built-in models — cross-checked against manufacturer specifications and Canadian and US availability. One honesty note: no lab publishes comparable numerical scores for built-in ice makers, so we show no scores rather than invent numbers. What we show is verified daily production, storage capacity, drain type and ice type for every machine. You can read Bob Vila’s full undercounter ice maker guide for their own take on the same shortlist.

Short on time? The EdgeStar IB120SS is the built-in most homes should buy, and the Scotsman CU50GA-1A is the entertainer’s machine. If plumbing is a non-starter, our guide to the best countertop ice makers covers the fill-and-go machines, chewable-ice fans should see our best nugget ice makers, and the rest of the home-bar setup is in our hosting and serving essentials.

Best Undercounter Ice Makers at a Glance

  1. EdgeStar IB120SS 15-Inch Built-In Ice Maker — Best Overall Undercounter Ice Maker
  2. KitchenAid KUIX335HPS 15-Inch Automatic Ice Maker — Best for Home Bars
  3. Scotsman CU50GA-1A Undercounter Ice Maker — Best Gourmet Clear Ice
  4. Scotsman CU50PA-1A Air-Cooled Ice Machine — Best Energy Star Certified
  5. KitchenAid KUIC18NNZS 18-Inch Automatic Ice Maker — Best Wide High-Capacity
  6. Euhomy Undercounter Commercial Ice Machine — Best Large-Capacity Output
  7. Whynter UIM-502SS Built-In Ice Maker — Best Built-In or Freestanding Flexibility
  8. Whynter UIM-155 Built-In Ice Maker — Best Small-Capacity Second Machine

How we score

The scores in this guide are CookSmartPicks’ own editorial ratings. We set them from our research of the expert reviews and sources listed in this post — they are our ratings, not scores quoted from another publication.

1. EdgeStar IB120SS 15-Inch Built-In Ice Maker — Best Overall Undercounter Ice Maker

Bob Vila’s Best Overall is the easiest built-in on this list to live with, because it skips the hardest part of installation: the IB120SS requires no drain. It produces up to 25 lbs of crescent ice per day and stores 20 lbs — a sensible household figure — in a standard 15-inch bay with a reversible stainless door. An ice scoop, the water line and a removable ice bin are all in the box, which keeps the install shopping list short.

CookSmartPicks score
9.1/10
Ice Output
8.0/10
Ice Quality
7.2/10
Installation Ease
9.6/10
Value
9.0/10

CookSmartPicks score — our own editorial rating, set from the research behind this guide (see “How we score” above).

Yay · Pros

  • No drain required — the simplest installation in this guide
  • 25 lbs per day with a generous 20 lb storage bin
  • Reversible door and a stainless finish that suits most kitchens
  • Scoop, water line and removable bin included

Hmm · Cons

  • No self-cleaning feature (Bob Vila)
  • Crescent ice is cloudy, not cocktail-clear
  • Mid-range output — heavy entertainers should look at the 50 lb class

Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com

2. KitchenAid KUIX335HPS 15-Inch Automatic Ice Maker — Best for Home Bars

Bob Vila’s pick for home bars pairs the standard 15-inch bay with output a class above: up to 50 lbs of ice per day and a 25 lb bin. KitchenAid’s Clear Ice Technology produces uniform, clear cubes that look right in a cocktail and melt evenly, the PrintShield finish resists fingerprints, and the machine installs fully flush with surrounding cabinetry on a reversible door. A self-cleaning cycle handles routine hygiene, and there is a slot for an optional water filter if your tap water needs help.

CookSmartPicks score
8.8/10
Ice Output
8.8/10
Ice Quality
9.4/10
Installation Ease
7.8/10
Value
8.0/10

CookSmartPicks score — our own editorial rating, set from the research behind this guide (see “How we score” above).

Yay · Pros

  • 50 lbs per day and 25 lbs of storage in a 15-inch bay
  • Clear Ice Technology — uniform, clear cubes for cocktails
  • Fully flush installation with a fingerprint-resistant finish
  • Self-cleaning cycle; optional filter slot

Hmm · Cons

  • The water filter is not included (Bob Vila)
  • No drain pump included — if your install needs one, it is a separate purchase (retailer specification)
  • Needs a full 25-inch-deep cutout, which catches out some cabinet runs

Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com

3. Scotsman CU50GA-1A Undercounter Ice Maker — Best Gourmet Clear Ice

Scotsman builds commercial ice machines, and the CU50GA-1A is its residential flagship: up to 65 lbs a day of clear, slow-melting gourmet cubes — the dense, top-hat style bars use for spirit-forward drinks — with 26 lbs of storage. Bob Vila named it their pick for hard water because a water-quality sensor detects mineral-heavy water and purges it, stretching the time between cleanings. It is also approved for outdoor use, which almost nothing else in this guide can claim. The GA in the name means gravity drain: your install needs a drain below the unit.

CookSmartPicks score
8.5/10
Ice Output
9.3/10
Ice Quality
9.6/10
Installation Ease
7.0/10
Value
7.4/10

CookSmartPicks score — our own editorial rating, set from the research behind this guide (see “How we score” above).

Yay · Pros

  • Clear gourmet cubes that melt slowly — the cocktail choice
  • 65 lbs per day with 26 lbs of storage
  • Water-quality sensor purges hard water to reduce scale buildup
  • Approved for outdoor installation

Hmm · Cons

  • Gravity drain required — the install must be planned around it
  • No self-cleaning feature (Bob Vila)
  • Commercial-grade build and pricing tier — the premium end of this list

Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com

4. Scotsman CU50PA-1A Air-Cooled Ice Machine — Best Energy Star Certified

The CU50PA-1A is the same Scotsman platform — 65 lbs a day of clear gourmet ice, 26 lbs of storage, outdoor-approved commercial construction — with two practical differences: the “P” adds a built-in drain pump, so the machine can push melt water up to a sink drain when no floor drain exists, and it carries Energy Star certification, which Bob Vila highlights for buyers watching running costs on an appliance that never switches off.

CookSmartPicks score
8.2/10
Ice Output
9.3/10
Ice Quality
9.6/10
Installation Ease
8.4/10
Value
7.2/10

CookSmartPicks score — our own editorial rating, set from the research behind this guide (see “How we score” above).

Yay · Pros

  • Built-in drain pump — no floor drain needed
  • Energy Star certified, unusual in this category
  • Same 65 lbs/day of clear gourmet ice as the CU50GA-1A
  • Outdoor approved, commercial-grade construction

Hmm · Cons

  • Operation can be loud when the machine is used indoors (Bob Vila)
  • The pump is one more component to maintain over the machine’s life
  • Premium pricing tier, like its gravity-drain sibling

Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com

5. KitchenAid KUIC18NNZS 18-Inch Automatic Ice Maker — Best Wide High-Capacity

If your cabinet run can spare 18 inches instead of 15, this is what the extra width buys: the same 50 lbs of daily production as the 15-inch KitchenAid, but the largest storage bin in this guide at 35 lbs — a full party’s worth of ice, made ahead and waiting. Clear Ice Technology produces uniform clear cubes, a built-in drain pump is included, and the bin is lit, with a filter keeping taste clean. Bob Vila named the 18-inch KitchenAid their Best Wide pick.

CookSmartPicks score
7.9/10
Ice Output
8.8/10
Ice Quality
9.4/10
Installation Ease
7.5/10
Value
7.8/10

CookSmartPicks score — our own editorial rating, set from the research behind this guide (see “How we score” above).

Yay · Pros

  • Largest storage here — 35 lbs of ice ready at once
  • 50 lbs per day with Clear Ice Technology
  • Built-in drain pump included
  • Lighted bin and water filtration

Hmm · Cons

  • Needs a full 18-inch-wide bay — measure before you fall in love
  • The drop-down door may not suit every kitchen layout (BestReviews)
  • Filter changes roughly every six months are an ongoing chore

Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com

6. Euhomy Undercounter Commercial Ice Machine — Best Large-Capacity Output

Bob Vila’s Best Large-Capacity pick is a commercial machine that happens to fit under a home counter: up to 100 lbs of cube ice per day and 33 lbs of storage, in stainless steel, with adjustable cube size, a timer and a self-cleaning cycle on the front panel. This is the machine for acreage bars, short-term rentals, offices and families who host in the dozens — anywhere a 50 lb machine would be emptied by dinner.

CookSmartPicks score
7.6/10
Ice Output
9.8/10
Ice Quality
8.0/10
Installation Ease
6.8/10
Value
7.6/10

CookSmartPicks score — our own editorial rating, set from the research behind this guide (see “How we score” above).

Yay · Pros

  • 100 lbs per day — double the residential machines here
  • 33 lbs of storage and adjustable cube size
  • Self-cleaning cycle and a timer on the control panel
  • Commercial stainless construction made for daily heavy use

Hmm · Cons

  • Gravity drainage required — a suitable drain must be installed (Bob Vila)
  • Output this large is wasted on a small household, and the bin still needs using or the ice cycles
  • Commercial styling over kitchen styling

Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com

7. Whynter UIM-502SS Built-In Ice Maker — Best Built-In or Freestanding Flexibility

The UIM-502SS makes up to 50 lbs of ice a day and stores 25 lbs, in a stainless cabinet that installs built-in under a counter or stands freestanding — genuinely useful if you rent, or if the remodel is coming but the parties are not waiting. It is a long-running, widely reviewed model in the appliance roundup literature, sized and specced squarely against the KitchenAid 15-inch at the heart of this category.

CookSmartPicks score
7.2/10
Ice Output
8.5/10
Ice Quality
7.5/10
Installation Ease
8.2/10
Value
7.4/10

CookSmartPicks score — our own editorial rating, set from the research behind this guide (see “How we score” above).

Yay · Pros

  • Installs built-in or freestanding — your choice, changeable later
  • 50 lbs per day with 25 lbs of storage
  • Stainless design that suits kitchens and bar areas

Hmm · Cons

  • Some users report frustrations with customer service (ApplianceMind)
  • Thinner dealer presence in Canada than KitchenAid or Scotsman — check the buttons for current availability
  • Cube ice is a step below the Scotsmans’ gourmet clarity

Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com

8. Whynter UIM-155 Built-In Ice Maker — Best Small-Capacity Second Machine

Bob Vila’s Best Small is the modest one: 12 lbs of crescent ice per day and 6 lbs of storage in a compact 25 × 15 × 18 inch cabinet that weighs just 52 lbs. What makes it interesting is what it does not need and what it does differently — it requires no drain, and unlike the melt-and-recycle bins on most small machines, its freezer compartment actually keeps stored ice frozen. It shuts off automatically when the bin is full, runs on one-button operation, and includes the scoop, bin and a 9-foot water line. Think of it as the second ice supply: a butler’s pantry, a primary suite, a small office kitchen.

CookSmartPicks score
6.7/10
Ice Output
5.5/10
Ice Quality
6.8/10
Installation Ease
9.0/10
Value
7.5/10

CookSmartPicks score — our own editorial rating, set from the research behind this guide (see “How we score” above).

Yay · Pros

  • No drain required, and the freezer compartment keeps ice genuinely frozen
  • Compact and light for a built-in — 52 lbs, 15 inches wide
  • Automatic shutoff when the bin is full
  • Scoop, bin and a 9-foot water line included

Hmm · Cons

  • Lowest output in this guide — a top-up machine, not a party machine
  • Crescent ice, not clear cubes
  • Not rated for outdoor use (Bob Vila)

Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com

How to Choose the Best Undercounter Ice Makers

Measure the bay before anything else. Most built-ins are 15 inches wide; 18-inch models like the big KitchenAid trade width for storage. Standard cutouts run about 34.5 inches high and 24–25 inches deep — the classic swap is a trash compactor or a little-used dishwasher. If the bay is not there, a plumbed machine is a renovation, and the fill-and-go machines in our countertop ice makers guide are the honest alternative.

The drain decision decides the install. Gravity-drain models (the Scotsman GA, the Euhomy) need a drain below the unit — simple if your plumbing rough-in allows it, a project if it does not. Pump models (the Scotsman PA, the big KitchenAid) push water up to a sink drain and forgive awkward layouts. And a small class of no-drain freezer models (the Whynter UIM-155, and the EdgeStar here needs no drain either) trades a refrigerated bin for installation simplicity. Know which of the three you are buying before the machine arrives.

Size output to your real peak, and storage to your parties. Production ratings assume ideal conditions; what matters on the night is how much ice is sitting in the bin when guests arrive, because the bin refills at a few pounds an hour, not instantly. A 25–35 lb bin covers most home entertaining — see our hosting and serving essentials for the rest of the bar. Only genuinely heavy use — rentals, offices, very large families — justifies the 100 lb commercial class.

Choose your ice last, but choose it deliberately. Crescent ice is fast and cloudy; cube ice from a clear-ice system is uniform and presentable; gourmet cubes are the dense, slow-melting cocktail choice. If your heart is set on chewable nugget ice, built-in nugget machines exist but live in a higher price class — our nugget ice makers guide covers the countertop route. Whatever you buy, plan for water quality: a filter or a self-purging sensor is the difference between a machine that lasts and one that scales up in a hard-water city.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do undercounter ice makers need a drain?

Most do — either a gravity drain below the unit or a model with a built-in pump that can push water to a sink drain. A few models avoid the question: freezer-style machines like the Whynter UIM-155 keep ice frozen instead of melting it, and the EdgeStar IB120SS in this guide also installs without a drain. Check the drain type before you buy, not after it arrives.

Can I install a built-in ice maker myself?

If a water line, a drain and an outlet already exist in the bay, a confident DIYer can level, connect and slide in a built-in in an afternoon. If any of the three has to be created — especially a new drain — that is a plumber’s job, and local codes in many Canadian and US municipalities require the water connection to be done or inspected by one. Budget the install as part of the purchase.

How much ice does a home bar actually need?

Work backwards from the bin, not the daily rating. A party of twelve drinking steadily will work through roughly 15–25 lbs of ice across an evening including cooler duty. A 50 lb-per-day machine with a 25 lb bin, started the day before, covers that without breaking a sweat; the 100 lb class is for rentals, offices and very large gatherings.

Why does my built-in ice maker produce cloudy ice or off tastes?

Cloudiness is trapped air and minerals — normal for crescent machines, and reduced by clear-ice systems. Off tastes usually mean the water filter is overdue or the machine needs its cleaning cycle run. In hard-water areas, descale on schedule and consider the models with water-quality sensors or filters in this guide.

Can an undercounter ice maker be installed outdoors?

Only if it is rated for it. Both Scotsman models in this guide are approved for outdoor use; standard indoor models are not, and cold winters in most of Canada will damage an unrated machine’s water lines. When in doubt, keep it indoors.

Last updated: November 1, 2026

More Ice Makers & Frozen Treats guides

All in this category →
Ninja CREAMi in Canada & the USA (NC301, Deluxe & Swirl Compared — Plus the Classic Alternatives)

Ninja CREAMi in Canada & the USA (NC301, Deluxe & Swirl Compared — Plus the Classic Alternatives)

Ninja CREAMi compared for Canada and the USA — NC301, Deluxe NC501 and Swirl NC701, plus a compressor…

Ice Makers & Frozen Treats · Updated 14 November 2026
Best Clear Ice Makers in Canada & the USA (2026): 7 Machines & Molds for Crystal-Clear Cocktail Ice

Best Clear Ice Makers in Canada & the USA (2026): 7 Machines & Molds for Crystal-Clear Cocktail Ice

If you are shopping for the best clear ice makers, you are really shopping for a way to freeze water in one…

Ice Makers & Frozen Treats · Updated 4 November 2026
Best Portable Ice Makers in Canada & the USA (2026): 8 Compact Machines for RVs, Camping & Parties

Best Portable Ice Makers in Canada & the USA (2026): 8 Compact Machines for RVs, Camping & Parties

If you are shopping for the best portable ice makers, the clue is in the name: these are the ice machines…

Ice Makers & Frozen Treats · Updated 4 November 2026

Why trust CookSmartPicks?

How we research

Every pick is compared across specs, verified owner reviews and independent expert sources before it earns a place here.

Editorial policy

Brands can’t pay for placement, rankings or reviews. Ever. Our order is decided by the research, not by advertisers.

Honest by design

We don’t fake hands-on testing. When a pick comes from research rather than our own countertop, we say so plainly.