153 guides · All researched, none sponsoredCanada & USA editions
Ice Makers & Frozen Treats

Best Clear Ice Makers in Canada & the USA (2026): 7 Machines & Molds for Crystal-Clear Cocktail Ice

Best Clear Ice Makers in Canada & the USA (2026): 7 Machines & Molds for Crystal-Clear Cocktail Ice

If you are shopping for the best clear ice makers, you are really shopping for a way to freeze water in one direction. Ordinary ice freezes from every side at once, which traps air and minerals in a cloudy white centre. Clear ice freezes directionally — top-down in an insulated mold, or as water flows over a chilled plate — so the air and impurities are pushed out instead of locked in. The result is dense, glass-clear ice that melts noticeably more slowly, dilutes a drink less, and keeps carbonated drinks fizzy for longer. It is the ice every serious cocktail bar uses, and it is absolutely achievable at home.

There are two families in this guide. Countertop machines freeze water over chilled grids to produce clear cubes in batches all day; directional systems — one countertop appliance and two freezer molds — trade speed for perfect, large 2-inch cubes. We built this ranking from the hands-on testing and published findings of Serious Eats, Wirecutter, The Spruce Eats, Food & Wine and Homes & Gardens, cross-checked against manufacturer specifications and current Canadian and US availability. One honesty note: the labs do not publish comparable numerical scores for clear ice makers, so we show no scores rather than invent numbers. Homes & Gardens’ hands-on ice maker testing reaches the same conclusion we do about which machine belongs at the top.

Short on time? The Luma Comfort IM200SS is the clear ice machine most people should buy. If what you actually want is chewable ice, read our best nugget ice makers instead; for general-purpose machines see the best countertop ice makers; and for the glassware and gear that complete a home bar, see our hosting and serving essentials.

Best Clear Ice Makers at a Glance

  1. Luma Comfort IM200SS Clear Ice Maker — Best Overall Clear Ice Maker
  2. Frigidaire EFIC452-SS Clear Ice Maker — Best High-Output Clear Ice
  3. Klaris Clear Ice Maker — Best Craft 2-Inch Cubes
  4. Klaris Mini Clear Ice Maker — Best Compact Craft Ice Maker
  5. ClearlyFrozen Clear Ice Tray — Best High-Capacity Clear Ice Mold
  6. True Cubes Crystal Clear Ice Cube Maker — Best Classic Clear Ice Mold
  7. Scotsman CU50GA-1A Undercounter Ice Maker — Best Built-In Clear Ice

How we score

The scores in this guide are CookSmartPicks’ own editorial ratings. We set them from our research of the expert reviews and sources listed in this post — they are our ratings, not scores quoted from another publication.

1. Luma Comfort IM200SS Clear Ice Maker — Best Overall Clear Ice Maker

The Luma is the closest thing this category has to a consensus pick: Wirecutter’s clear-ice recommendation, Serious Eats’ winner for cocktails, The Spruce Eats’ Best Overall and a Food & Wine Best Overall nod as well. It freezes water over a chilled grid in batches roughly three times larger than a bullet machine’s — a cycle takes 20 to 24 minutes — and the ice is dense and consistently clear: in Wirecutter’s testing it lasted more than an hour in a glass of room-temperature water. The Spruce Eats found its 10-cup reservoir produced the highest hourly output of the machines they tested, and that it runs essentially silently. Two ice-thickness settings let you adjust for a warm room.

It is not small, and the cubes freeze together as a slab you break apart before serving — a minor ritual, but one worth knowing about.

CookSmartPicks score
9.3/10
Ice Quality
9.6/10
Speed & Output
8.8/10
Ease of Use
8.5/10
Value
8.4/10

CookSmartPicks score — our own editorial rating, set from the research behind this guide (see “How we score” above).

Yay · Pros

  • The clearest, densest countertop ice in expert testing — Serious Eats’ pick for cocktails
  • Runs near-silently (The Spruce Eats) — home-bar friendly
  • Big batches, about three times a bullet machine’s per cycle
  • Side drain spout makes emptying easy — the only machine in Serious Eats’ test with one, so no lifting it over the sink

Hmm · Cons

  • Large footprint — about 14.8 × 11.3 × 14.1 inches; it will crowd a small counter
  • No viewing window and no self-cleaning cycle
  • Ice freezes in a slab you break apart before serving

Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com

2. Frigidaire EFIC452-SS Clear Ice Maker — Best High-Output Clear Ice

Where the Luma is a craftsman, the EFIC452 is a workhorse: up to 40 lbs of clear, square ice per day, in batches of 24 cubes every 15 minutes or so, in your choice of two cube sizes. A 2.3-quart water tank feeds production, a transparent window lets you watch the supply, and the whole thing wears a familiar Frigidaire badge with the support network that implies. Wirecutter included the EFIC452 among the clear-ice models in its most recent testing pool — it is the machine to look at when a household or a party needs clear ice in volume, not four cubes at a time.

CookSmartPicks score
9.0/10
Ice Quality
9.0/10
Speed & Output
9.5/10
Ease of Use
8.4/10
Value
8.6/10

CookSmartPicks score — our own editorial rating, set from the research behind this guide (see “How we score” above).

Yay · Pros

  • 40 lbs of clear square ice per day — the highest output of the countertop machines here
  • Fast batches: 24 cubes in about 15 minutes
  • Two cube sizes and a viewing window
  • Big-brand support network in Canada and the USA

Hmm · Cons

  • The 2.4 lb basket is small against 40 lbs of daily output — you will empty it into the freezer constantly
  • A large countertop footprint, roughly 14.8 × 11 × 14.1 inches
  • First batch takes 15–18 minutes — slower than a bullet machine’s sprint

Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com

3. Klaris Clear Ice Maker — Best Craft 2-Inch Cubes

The Klaris is directional freezing in an appliance: a countertop device that freezes water slowly downward to produce four flawless 2-inch cubes per cycle — the big, slow-melting rocks a whisky or an old fashioned deserves. A cycle takes 8 to 12 hours; run it twice a day and you can bank up to eight cubes daily. A delayed-start timer (2, 4 or 8 hours) means a batch can be ready when you walk in, and once frozen the machine holds the cubes just below freezing for up to six hours. It weighs about 9 lbs and takes up less than a square foot of counter.

CookSmartPicks score
8.6/10
Ice Quality
9.5/10
Speed & Output
6.8/10
Ease of Use
8.0/10
Value
7.8/10

CookSmartPicks score — our own editorial rating, set from the research behind this guide (see “How we score” above).

Yay · Pros

  • True directional-frozen 2-inch cubes — the craft-bar standard
  • Delayed start, so cubes are ready on your schedule
  • Compact and light: roughly 9 lbs, under a square foot
  • Holds finished cubes cold for up to 6 hours

Hmm · Cons

  • Four cubes per cycle — plan a day or more ahead for a party
  • Not a freezer: after the hold window, cubes belong in freezer storage
  • A specialist tool, not a household ice supply

Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com

4. Klaris Mini Clear Ice Maker — Best Compact Craft Ice Maker

The Mini shrinks the Klaris formula for smaller bars and kitchens: two 2-inch directional-frozen cubes per cycle of 8 to 10 hours, with up to two cycles a day. Its quiet advantage over the original is patience — it keeps finished cubes frozen for up to 24 hours, four times the original’s hold, so a batch made in the morning is still perfect for an evening drink. It is sold through Williams Sonoma in both the US and Canada.

CookSmartPicks score
8.3/10
Ice Quality
9.4/10
Speed & Output
6.5/10
Ease of Use
8.6/10
Value
7.5/10

CookSmartPicks score — our own editorial rating, set from the research behind this guide (see “How we score” above).

Yay · Pros

  • Holds finished cubes up to 24 hours — the most forgiving schedule in this guide
  • The smallest craft-ice appliance here
  • The same 2-inch directional-frozen cubes as the original Klaris
  • Simple one-button operation

Hmm · Cons

  • Just two cubes per cycle
  • Still 8–10 hours per batch — there is no rushing directional ice
  • You pay for miniaturization, not volume

Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com

5. ClearlyFrozen Clear Ice Tray — Best High-Capacity Clear Ice Mold

If you would rather spend freezer space than counter space, ClearlyFrozen is the mold the experts reach for: Liquor.com’s Best Overall clear ice mold and Food & Wine’s pick for clear cocktail ice. An insulated box and a BPA-free silicone mold freeze ten 2-inch cubes directionally — two to three times the batch of rival molds — pushing air and impurities down through holes in the mold into a reservoir below. It works with ordinary tap water in an ordinary freezer, and its open-top design means there is no precise timing window to hit or miss. A warning owners repeat: the foam insulation box is part of the product, not packaging. Do not throw it away.

CookSmartPicks score
8.0/10
Ice Quality
9.2/10
Speed & Output
6.8/10
Ease of Use
7.8/10
Value
8.8/10

CookSmartPicks score — our own editorial rating, set from the research behind this guide (see “How we score” above).

Yay · Pros

  • Ten 2-inch clear cubes per batch — the most of any mold here
  • Liquor.com’s Best Overall clear ice mold; Food & Wine’s pick for cocktail ice
  • No timing window to babysit, and plain tap water works
  • Interchangeable molds exist for smaller cubes and spears

Hmm · Cons

  • The insulated box takes real freezer space
  • Each batch still needs the better part of a day in the freezer
  • Finished cubes need a bag or box for storage once frozen

Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com

6. True Cubes Crystal Clear Ice Cube Maker — Best Classic Clear Ice Mold

True Cubes is the original insulated directional-freezing system for home freezers and the winner of America’s Test Kitchen’s clear ice mold testing. Fill it with regular tap water, give it 18 to 22 hours, and it returns four large 2 × 2 × 2 inch cubes — dense, clear and slow-melting. No electricity, no counter space, no settings. It remains the benchmark the newer molds are measured against, and the simplest recommendation for a first clear-ice experiment.

CookSmartPicks score
7.7/10
Ice Quality
9.0/10
Speed & Output
6.5/10
Ease of Use
8.0/10
Value
8.5/10

CookSmartPicks score — our own editorial rating, set from the research behind this guide (see “How we score” above).

Yay · Pros

  • America’s Test Kitchen’s clear ice mold winner
  • Proven clarity with plain tap water
  • No electricity and nothing to maintain

Hmm · Cons

  • Only four cubes per batch
  • Roughly a day per batch, like every directional system
  • Needs room in the freezer for the insulated unit

Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com

7. Scotsman CU50GA-1A Undercounter Ice Maker — Best Built-In Clear Ice

For clear ice in real volume there is exactly one route: a plumbed machine. The Scotsman CU50GA-1A makes up to 65 lbs a day of clear gourmet cubes — the dense, slow-melting top-hat style — and stores 26 lbs, ready around the clock, with a water-quality sensor that purges mineral-heavy water to protect both clarity and the machine. It is the same commercial-grade platform that anchors our built-in ice maker research, and for a dedicated home bar it ends the clear-ice question permanently. The commitment is real, though: it needs a water line, a gravity drain and a 15-inch cabinet bay.

CookSmartPicks score
7.3/10
Ice Quality
9.2/10
Speed & Output
9.6/10
Ease of Use
6.8/10
Value
6.5/10

CookSmartPicks score — our own editorial rating, set from the research behind this guide (see “How we score” above).

Yay · Pros

  • Clear gourmet ice by the tens of pounds — the only high-volume clear option
  • Slow-melting top-hat cubes, stored and ready around the clock
  • Plumbed — no refilling, no batches to schedule
  • Water-quality sensor helps in hard-water homes

Hmm · Cons

  • Needs a water line, a gravity drain and a 15-inch cabinet bay
  • No self-cleaning cycle (Bob Vila)
  • A major-appliance commitment for an ice upgrade

Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com

How to Choose the Best Clear Ice Makers

Decide first between a machine and a mold. Machines (the Luma, the Frigidaire, the Scotsman) make clear ice continuously and suit households that ice drinks daily or entertain often. Directional systems (Klaris, ClearlyFrozen, True Cubes) make fewer, better cubes — perfect 2-inch rocks — and suit the one-great-drink-at-home ritual, provided you have the freezer space and the habit of starting a batch the day before. Neither is better in the abstract; they serve different drinkers.

Know what the clarity is buying you. Clear ice is dense because it holds almost no trapped air, so it melts slowly, dilutes less, and — as Wirecutter’s testing notes — keeps carbonated drinks fizzy longer than cloudy ice does. If your drinks are mostly soda and juice, that advantage is small; if they are whisky, negronis and old fashioneds, it is the whole point. Complete the setup with the glassware and tools in our hosting and serving essentials guide.

Match cube size to the glass. A single 2-inch cube suits spirit-forward drinks — maximum chill, minimum surface area. Grid-machine cubes are smaller and suit highballs, sodas and everyday use. And be honest about volume: a cocktail night for six needs roughly a dozen to eighteen large cubes, which a Klaris owner starts two days out and a Luma owner makes the same afternoon. If what you are really after is soft, chewable ice rather than clarity, that is a different machine entirely — see our nugget ice makers guide — and for mixed everyday needs, our countertop ice makers guide covers the all-rounders.

Finally, water matters less than method. Directional freezing handles ordinary tap water well because the impurities are physically pushed out of the cube. Grid-style machines also work with tap water, but filtered water improves both clarity and taste and slows scale buildup — the same cleaning discipline as any ice machine applies: descale on schedule, more often in hard-water areas.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is clear ice better for cocktails?

Clear ice is dense, with almost no trapped air, so it melts more slowly than cloudy ice and dilutes the drink less as it chills. Wirecutter’s testing also found that clear cubes keep carbonated drinks fizzy for longer, because there are fewer trapped-air nucleation points for the bubbles to attack. And, honestly, it looks like a bar made your drink.

Can I make clear ice just by boiling the water first?

Boiling drives off some dissolved air and can reduce cloudiness slightly, but on its own it will not give you bar-clear ice — a boiled tray still freezes from all sides at once and traps what is left in the middle. The reliable route is directional freezing, whether that is an insulated mold, a Klaris appliance, or a machine freezing over a chilled grid.

How long do clear ice molds take?

Plan on the better part of a day. True Cubes specifies 18 to 22 hours for its four-cube batch, and the other directional systems in this guide are in the same range — the Klaris appliance takes 8 to 12 hours per cycle because it controls the freezing actively. Clear ice is a plan-ahead product; the countertop grid machines are the impatient option.

Do clear ice makers need distilled water?

No. Directional systems are designed for ordinary tap water — the freezing process itself pushes minerals and air out of the cube. Filtered water is still worth using in any ice machine for taste and to slow scale, and grid-style machines like the Luma and Frigidaire produce their clearest results with it, but distilled water is not required by any pick in this guide.

How many 2-inch clear cubes do I need per drink?

One per spirit-forward drink — a single large cube is the point. For a cocktail night, count one cube per guest per round, plus a few spares for breakage and seconds. Store finished cubes in a sealed bag or box in the freezer; directional cubes keep well for weeks, though they slowly pick up freezer odours if left uncovered.

Last updated: November 1, 2026

More Ice Makers & Frozen Treats guides

All in this category →
Ninja CREAMi in Canada & the USA (NC301, Deluxe & Swirl Compared — Plus the Classic Alternatives)

Ninja CREAMi in Canada & the USA (NC301, Deluxe & Swirl Compared — Plus the Classic Alternatives)

Ninja CREAMi compared for Canada and the USA — NC301, Deluxe NC501 and Swirl NC701, plus a compressor…

Ice Makers & Frozen Treats · Updated 14 November 2026
Best Undercounter & Built-In Ice Makers in Canada & the USA (2026): 8 Plumbed Picks for Kitchens & Home Bars

Best Undercounter & Built-In Ice Makers in Canada & the USA (2026): 8 Plumbed Picks for Kitchens & Home Bars

If you are shopping for the best undercounter ice makers, you are shopping for a different species of…

Ice Makers & Frozen Treats · Updated 5 November 2026
Best Portable Ice Makers in Canada & the USA (2026): 8 Compact Machines for RVs, Camping & Parties

Best Portable Ice Makers in Canada & the USA (2026): 8 Compact Machines for RVs, Camping & Parties

If you are shopping for the best portable ice makers, the clue is in the name: these are the ice machines…

Ice Makers & Frozen Treats · Updated 4 November 2026

Why trust CookSmartPicks?

How we research

Every pick is compared across specs, verified owner reviews and independent expert sources before it earns a place here.

Editorial policy

Brands can’t pay for placement, rankings or reviews. Ever. Our order is decided by the research, not by advertisers.

Honest by design

We don’t fake hands-on testing. When a pick comes from research rather than our own countertop, we say so plainly.