153 guides · All researched, none sponsoredCanada & USA editions
Drinkware

Best Soda Makers in Canada & the USA (Sparkling Water Machines Compared)

Best Soda Makers in Canada & the USA (Sparkling Water Machines Compared)

A soda maker does one simple thing — it forces CO2 into cold water until the water fights back with fizz — and yet the machines split into three genuinely different products. The classic machines from SodaStream, Aarke and Philips carbonate water only, and you add flavour afterwards. Drinkmate’s machine carbonates almost any cold drink you pour in, juice and cocktails included. Ninja’s Thirsti is a flavour system first: pods, carbonation levels and a machine built around them. Choosing a soda maker is therefore really choosing an ecosystem — which gas cylinders it takes, where you will exchange them, and what you are allowed to put in the bottle. Get that decision right and the machine itself is the easy part. Get it wrong and you own a countertop ornament with an expensive gas habit. This guide compares the five machines worth buying in Canada and the USA, and it starts where the real money is: the CO2.

One seasonal note before the lineup: soda makers are a staple of holiday gift lists, and our Black Friday kitchen deals watchlist tracks which kitchen categories are genuinely discounted this season — worth a look before you pay full price for any machine below.

Disclosure: CookSmartPicks is reader-supported. When you buy through links on this page, we may earn an Amazon commission at no extra cost to you. Prices and availability change often — check the current price on Amazon before you decide.

How we chose these soda makers

CookSmartPicks is a research-based guide. We do not run a test lab, and we never claim hands-on testing we have not done. For this list we compared manufacturer specifications — cylinder systems, bottle sizes, materials and what each machine is officially rated to carbonate — with the market and category coverage in our 2026-11-14 keyword research: the soda maker market is sized at 1.19 billion US dollars for 2026 and growing at 8.3% a year, with North America the largest region and SodaStream holding roughly a quarter of the market (Global Market Insights figures, accessed November 2026). Every pick below earned its place on a documented difference — cylinder compatibility, what it can carbonate, build, or footprint — and every running-cost claim is framed as exchange logistics rather than invented prices, because gas pricing varies by store and by country.

The lineup at a glance

MachineBest forWhy it stands out
SodaStream TerraMost peopleThe default pick — snap-lock bottles and Quick Connect cylinders with the widest exchange network in both countries
Drinkmate OmniFizzCarbonating more than waterThe Fizz Infuser carbonates juice, tea, wine and cocktails; takes standard 60 L screw-in cylinders
Ninja ThirstiFlavour loversBuilt around Ninja’s flavour pods, with selectable carbonation levels and a sleek countertop format
Aarke Carbonator 3Design-first kitchensStainless-steel lever machine, standard cylinders, the one soda maker people leave on display
Philips GoZero Soda MakerValue and small countersSlim, simple, standard-cylinder machine without the ecosystem extras

1. SodaStream Terra — Best for most people

SodaStream Terra

The Terra is SodaStream’s current mainstream machine and the one most households should buy. It is a slim, electricity-free tower: fill the included 1-litre bottle to the line with cold water, snap it into the locking mechanism — no screwing, which matters more than it sounds at the third bottle of the day — press the top button in short bursts, and the water is sparkling in under a minute. The Terra uses SodaStream’s Quick Connect cylinders (the pink-labelled ones), which click in and out in seconds instead of threading, and a full cylinder carbonates up to roughly 60 litres of water depending on how aggressive your fizz is. SodaStream’s exchange network is the real product here: empties swap for full cylinders at grocery, big-box and kitchen stores across both countries, and that network is the largest of any brand on this page.

The honest limits are the ecosystem walls. The Terra carbonates water only — SodaStream is explicit that flavour goes in after carbonation, and carbonating anything else risks a foamy mess and a voided warranty. Quick Connect cylinders are also not interchangeable with the older blue screw-in SodaStream cylinders, so households upgrading from an older machine cannot carry their old gas stock over. And the build is plastic: functional, light and easy to wipe down, but nobody will mistake it for an heirloom. None of that changes the verdict for most people — the machine is the cheap part of soda making, the gas is the subscription, and SodaStream’s subscription is the easiest one to feed in Canada and the USA.

Yay · Pros

  • The widest CO2 exchange network in Canada and the USA — gas is never a scavenger hunt
  • Quick Connect cylinders swap in seconds, and snap-lock bottles beat thread-in bottles daily
  • No electricity, small footprint, works during a power outage and at a cabin

Hmm · Cons

  • Carbonates water only — flavour must be added after
  • Quick Connect (pink) cylinders do not fit older screw-in SodaStream machines, or vice versa
  • Plastic build feels ordinary next to the Aarke

Best for: most households making the switch from canned sparkling water — the safe, supported default. Skip if: you want to carbonate juice or cocktails (that is Drinkmate’s party trick), or you already own a stock of old blue screw-in cylinders.

2. Drinkmate OmniFizz — Best for carbonating more than water

Drinkmate OmniFizz

Drinkmate built its whole identity around the thing SodaStream forbids. The OmniFizz’s patented Fizz Infuser is a slow-release carbonation cap that lets the machine carbonate any cold liquid — juice, iced tea, lemonade, sports drinks, wine and cocktails — and then release the pressure slowly so the drink does not erupt on opening. That single difference opens uses no water-only machine can touch: reviving flat soda, sparkling a batch of sangria, fizzing cold brew for a nitro-style texture. The second difference is the gas: the OmniFizz takes standard 60-litre screw-in CO2 cylinders — the long-standing thread standard — which means it accepts Drinkmate’s own cylinders and the widely exchanged blue SodaStream-style cylinders, giving you more places to swap gas than any proprietary system.

The trade-offs are technique and tidiness. Carbonating sugary or pulpy drinks takes a slower hand — short bursts, a rest, and a slow release — and the infuser and bottle need rinsing after anything stickier than water, where a water-only machine can go weeks between wipes. Drinkmate’s own retail exchange footprint is smaller than SodaStream’s in Canada, which is precisely why the standard-cylinder compatibility matters: you are not dependent on Drinkmate’s network, you can exchange anywhere the standard cylinders are taken. If your household drinks plain sparkling water and nothing else, this machine’s talent is wasted on you. If your fridge holds flat lemonade and leftover prosecco, nothing else on this page does what it does.

Yay · Pros

  • Carbonates almost any cold liquid — juice, tea, wine, cocktails — not just water
  • Standard 60 L screw-in cylinders: the broadest compatibility of any machine here
  • No electricity; the Fizz Infuser’s slow release prevents the geyser problem

Hmm · Cons

  • Sugary drinks demand technique and a rinse afterwards — more fuss than water-only machines
  • Drinkmate’s own exchange network is thinner in Canada (mitigated by standard cylinders)
  • Plain-water households pay for a talent they will never use

Best for: anyone who wants sparkling everything — flat-soda rescuers, cocktail makers, juice households. Skip if: you only ever drink plain sparkling water; the Terra is simpler and its gas is easier to find.

3. Ninja Thirsti — Best for flavours

Ninja Thirsti

Ninja looked at the soda maker category and asked why the flavour lives in a separate syrup bottle. The Thirsti is built around Ninja’s own flavour pods — concentrated, mostly zero-sugar drops that click into the machine and dispense into the glass as you pour — paired with selectable carbonation levels, so one press produces anything from a lightly sparkling flavoured water to a properly aggressive soda. For households whose sparkling-water habit is really a flavoured sparkling-water habit — the people keeping LaCroix and Bubly in business — it removes the syrup-measuring step entirely and keeps the counter cleaner. Ninja’s arrival matters in the market data too: our research notes the Thirsti has already pushed into the category’s top five brands.

The catch is written into the design: this is the most closed ecosystem on the page. The flavour pods are Ninja’s, the CO2 comes in Ninja’s own cartridges rather than the standard 60-litre cylinders the rest of this list shares, and both are ongoing purchases from one supplier. Cartridges are smaller than a 60-litre cylinder, so heavy households will swap gas more often, and if Ninja ever retires the pod line, the machine’s main trick retires with it. None of that makes it a bad buy — it makes it a deliberate one. Price the pods and cartridges as a subscription before you commit, and if the flavours are the point of the purchase for your household, the Thirsti does that job better than bolting syrup onto a water-only machine.

Yay · Pros

  • Flavour pods dispense as you pour — no syrup bottles, no measuring, no sticky counter
  • Selectable carbonation levels, from light sparkle to full soda bite
  • The most modern format in the category, from a brand now in its top five

Hmm · Cons

  • Fully proprietary consumables — pods and CO2 cartridges come from Ninja only
  • Smaller CO2 cartridges mean more frequent swaps for heavy users
  • Carbonates water; the flavour system does not turn it into a carbonate-anything machine

Best for: flavoured-sparkling households — the people whose grocery bill already includes cases of flavoured water. Skip if: you want standard-cylinder freedom or the lowest possible running cost per litre.

4. Aarke Carbonator 3 — Best premium design

Aarke Carbonator 3

The Carbonator 3 is the soda maker for people who hate appliance plastic. Aarke builds it in Sweden around a stainless-steel body with a long, satisfying lever: bottle in, lever down, and the machine carbonates with a mechanical directness that button machines do not imitate. It takes the standard 60-litre screw-in CO2 cylinders — the same broad-compatibility standard as the Drinkmate — and carbonates water only, with flavour added afterwards. Details are considered in a way the category rarely manages: a stainless drip tray, a bottle with a steel cap and base, and an over-pressure release that hisses at exactly the right moment. It is, by a distance, the machine on this page that people photograph on their counters.

You pay for all of it, in the only currency this site discusses honestly: the machine itself is the premium purchase in the category, several times the price of the value picks, while the drink it produces is — blindfolded — the same sparkling water. The lever mechanism also asks for a touch more intention than a button: over-carbonating wastes gas, and Aarke’s own guidance is a couple of firm pulls, not five enthusiastic ones. Buy it because you will use it daily for years and want the object itself to earn its counter space, not because the water tastes different. On those terms it is the easiest premium recommendation in this guide.

Yay · Pros

  • Stainless-steel build and lever action — the best-made machine in the category
  • Standard 60 L screw-in cylinders keep gas exchanges easy and brand-flexible
  • Compact, display-worthy design with thoughtful details (steel-capped bottle, drip tray)

Hmm · Cons

  • The premium price buys build and design, not better-tasting water
  • Water only — no carbonating other drinks
  • Lever technique matters: extra pulls just waste gas

Best for: daily users with design-first kitchens who will keep one machine for a decade. Skip if: budget buyers, or anyone who wants to carbonate more than water.

5. Philips GoZero Soda Maker — Best value slim pick

Philips GoZero Soda Maker

Philips’ GoZero soda maker is the quiet value entry: a slim, electricity-free machine that carbonates water using standard 60-litre screw-in CO2 cylinders, with a straightforward press-down carbonation control that lets you judge fizz by feel and repetition rather than electronics. The slim body is the point — it is one of the narrowest machines in the category, made for apartment counters and the gap beside the fridge — and the standard-cylinder choice keeps its running costs in the same sensible territory as the Drinkmate and Aarke instead of a proprietary cartridge system. Philips sells it as part of its GoZero water range, and in both Canada and the USA it is routinely the big-brand machine found at the friendly end of the price range.

What you give up is ecosystem depth. Philips does not surround the GoZero with SodaStream’s exchange-everywhere presence or Ninja’s flavour theatre; bottles and parts are Philips’ own, and the machine carbonates water only. The carbonation control is also the simplest here — no selectable levels, just your own timing — which some users will find liberating and others imprecise. As a first soda maker, or a second one for a cabin or office kitchen, it is exactly the right amount of machine.

Yay · Pros

  • Slim body — among the narrowest footprints in the category
  • Standard 60 L screw-in cylinders: sensible running costs, no proprietary lock-in
  • Big-brand value pick in both countries, with simple, electricity-free operation

Hmm · Cons

  • Water only, and no flavour system of its own
  • No selectable carbonation levels — fizz is judged by hand
  • Smaller accessory and bottle ecosystem than SodaStream’s

Best for: first-time buyers, small kitchens, cabins and offices — the right amount of machine for the money. Skip if: you want flavours built in (Thirsti) or carbonate-anything freedom (Drinkmate).

The CO2 question: the real cost of a soda maker

Every machine above is a one-time purchase; the gas is the subscription, and it is where Canada and the USA genuinely differ. Three cylinder systems appear in this guide. SodaStream’s Quick Connect (pink) cylinders fit only current SodaStream machines and exchange through SodaStream’s network — the largest in both countries. The standard 60 L screw-in thread (Drinkmate, Aarke, Philips) is the older, wider standard: cylinders from several brands fit several machines, and exchanges are handled by kitchen retailers, big-box stores and mail-in programs. Ninja’s Thirsti uses its own smaller cartridges, bought from Ninja and its retailers. A full-size cylinder carbonates up to about 60 litres at moderate fizz; heavy fizz drinkers get less. Before choosing a machine, check which cylinders your actual local stores exchange — in much of Canada that means Canadian Tire, Walmart and kitchen stores — because a machine whose gas requires a special trip is a machine that quietly stops being used. And one boundary worth stating: if your goal is cleaner-tasting tap water rather than fizz, a soda maker is the wrong appliance — our guide to the best countertop reverse osmosis water filters covers the filtration side of the counter.

How to choose the right soda maker

Decide what gets carbonated. Plain water only? Any machine here works, and the choice becomes gas and build. Anything else — juice, wine, flat soda — narrows the field to exactly one: the Drinkmate. Flavoured water as the main event points at the Thirsti. Decide your gas before your machine. The cylinder system is the running cost and the errand; standard screw-in cylinders maximise your exchange options, Quick Connect maximises convenience inside SodaStream’s network, and proprietary cartridges maximise simplicity at a premium. Count your litres. A household carbonating two litres a day empties a 60-litre cylinder roughly monthly; keeping a spare cylinder at home is the difference between a habit and a hassle. Then, and only then, choose the object — plastic value (Philips), mainstream ease (Terra), or the stainless lever machine (Aarke) that turns a chore into a small daily pleasure.

Soda maker questions, answered

Is a soda maker actually cheaper than buying sparkling water?

For regular drinkers, yes — that is the category’s founding maths. A cylinder carbonates up to roughly 60 litres, and even adding the machine’s purchase price, a household replacing a case-a-week canned water habit typically comes out ahead within the first year, with the exact payback depending on local cylinder exchange pricing, which varies by store and country. The honest exception is the occasional drinker: if a case of sparkling water lasts you a month, the machine is a convenience purchase, not a savings one.

Can I carbonate juice, wine or flat soda in a SodaStream?

No — and this is the most common expensive mistake in the category. SodaStream, Aarke and Philips machines are rated for water only; carbonating sugary liquids in them can foam over, damage seals and void warranties. If carbonating other drinks is on your list, the Drinkmate OmniFizz is built and warranted for exactly that, with its slow-release Fizz Infuser. Flavour in a water-only machine goes in after carbonation, in the glass or the bottle.

Are CO2 cylinders interchangeable between brands?

Partly — and the thread is what matters. The standard 60 L screw-in cylinders used by Drinkmate, Aarke and Philips share a thread standard, and cylinders from those brands (and the older blue SodaStream screw-in cylinders) are broadly cross-compatible. SodaStream’s newer Quick Connect (pink) cylinders fit only Quick Connect machines. Ninja Thirsti cartridges fit only the Thirsti. When in doubt, match the thread, not the logo.

Where do I exchange cylinders in Canada?

SodaStream exchanges run through major grocery, big-box and kitchen retailers across Canada, including Canadian Tire and Walmart locations; standard screw-in cylinders exchange at many of the same kitchen retailers, and mail-in exchange programs cover rural areas in both countries. Keep a spare cylinder at home so an empty never interrupts the habit, and never throw an empty cylinder in household recycling — exchanges and returns are the system working as designed.

The short version

For most people, the SodaStream Terra is the soda maker to buy — the easiest machine, fed by the largest exchange network in Canada and the USA. If you want to carbonate more than water, the Drinkmate OmniFizz stands alone, and its standard cylinders keep gas simple. Flavour-first households should look at the Ninja Thirsti and price its pods as the subscription they are. The Aarke Carbonator 3 is the premium object — same water, far better machine — and the Philips GoZero is the slim value pick that asks for the least money and counter space. Whichever you choose, choose the gas first: the cylinder system you can exchange around the corner is the one you will still be using next year. Soda makers also make genuinely good gifts for the sparkling-water devotee on your list — our guide to the best kitchen gifts in Canada and the USA has more ideas in that spirit, and if your sparkling habit leans toward fresh juice instead, our best cold press juicers guide is the other side of the counter.

Last updated: November 15, 2026. We refresh this guide each season and whenever a pick is replaced by a better one.

More Drinkware guides

All in this category →
Best Travel Mugs in Canada & the USA (2026): 8 Leakproof Picks for Hot Coffee on the Go

Best Travel Mugs in Canada & the USA (2026): 8 Leakproof Picks for Hot Coffee on the Go

If you are shopping for the best travel mugs, be clear about the job first: this guide is about commuter…

Drinkware · Updated 6 November 2026
Best Water Bottles in Canada & the USA (2026): 8 Leakproof Picks with Straw and Sports Lids

Best Water Bottles in Canada & the USA (2026): 8 Leakproof Picks with Straw and Sports Lids

If you are shopping for the best water bottles, be clear about the job first: a bottle is the sealed,…

Drinkware · Updated 5 November 2026
10 Best Insulated Tumblers & Travel Mugs in Canada & the USA (2026): Research-Based Picks That Keep Drinks Cold or Hot for Hours

10 Best Insulated Tumblers & Travel Mugs in Canada & the USA (2026): Research-Based Picks That Keep Drinks Cold or Hot for Hours

Simple+Modern Vacuum insulation itself is basically a solved technology — Consumer Reports has found the…

Drinkware · Updated 6 November 2026

Why trust CookSmartPicks?

How we research

Every pick is compared across specs, verified owner reviews and independent expert sources before it earns a place here.

Editorial policy

Brands can’t pay for placement, rankings or reviews. Ever. Our order is decided by the research, not by advertisers.

Honest by design

We don’t fake hands-on testing. When a pick comes from research rather than our own countertop, we say so plainly.